Pdf assessing the impact of an eu financial transactions tax on. A financial transactions tax is a lovely idea but it does have one rather large failure in that it doesnt in fact gain any extra tax revenue, far from it it reduces total collections. The massive financial market failures that led to the great recession have prompted renewed calls for a financial transaction tax ftt to discourage excessive risk taking and recoup the costs of the crisis. It is synonymous with other terms such as securities transaction tax and securities transfer tax. Financial transaction tax survey an overview of the eight eu member states considered to apply a tax on financial transactions. Broadly, the ftt is a proposal to tax each secondary financial transaction involving shares, bonds and the entering into and secondary trading of derivatives.
Where the tax due has not been paid within the time limit set out in article 115, each party to a transaction, including persons other than financial institutions shall be jointly and severally liable for the payment of the tax due by a financial institution on account of that transaction. The communication also announced an impact assessment ia further. As a former hedge fund manager who supports a financial transaction tax ftt, i realize i am somewhat uncommon. John maynard keynes proposed charging some form of tax for financial transactions in the early twentieth century, as did nobel laureate james tobin in the 1970s, whose eponymous tax encapsulates the idea of throwing sand in the wheel to slow down excessive trading in the market in the current economic and political climate, as.
European commission, ommission staff working paper. The introduction of a financial transactions tax at eu level will likely have a great impact on the fund industry. Investment funds performance and financial transactions tax. Taxation of the financial sector european commission. Impact assessment accompanying the document proposal for a ouncil directive on a common system of financial transaction tax and amending directive 20087e september 2011 with a tax rate of 0. The original eu impact assessment suggested that the overall tax revenues for eu27. At the time of writing of the ecs first impact assessment, ten member states had. The aim of this paper is to investigate the impact of financial transaction tax ftt on the stability of financial market. The case for and against the eu financial transaction tax. Annex 1 key arguments for and against the european commission s proposal annex 2 outline of the european commission s proposal 17 annex 3 the impact of the ftt on eu11 financial markets 21 annex 4 the wider impact of the ftt 26 annex 5 lessons from national ftts 32 annex 6 bibliography 42 annex 7 list of. Implications of a financial transactions tax for the. Exhibit 2 shows this analysis for eu11 debt and equity securities. The concept of this tax is supported by france and germany yet is strongly opposed by uk and some other eu member states. Studies highlighting the damaging impacts of a financial.
This paper estimates the revenue potential of a financial transaction tax ftt for u. Introduction of a european financial transaction tax ftt 5 3. Entitled living, working and covid19, the aim of the survey is to investigate the impact on wellbeing, work and telework and on the financial situation of. Financial transaction tax kpmg global kpmg international. The commissions proposal for a financial transaction tax ftt aims at. Impact of eu financial transaction tax on the asset. Financial transaction taxes in the european union national tax. A financial transactions tax is, as the name suggests, a tax on each and every financial transaction. Table 29 empirical estimates on gdp effects of an ftt 54. Pdf under the context of emu debt and financial crisis, we assess the impact of emus announcement of a financial transactions tax ftt. The 10 european union countries still plotting a tax on financial transactions tied the proposals fate to the outcome of the brexit negotiations, pushing any decision on the sixyearold plan. After a lengthy period of debate aimed at establishing cooperation between eu member states for the purposes of creating a common system of financial transaction tax ftt also known as the tobin tax after the economist who initially. The tax would be levied on all transactions on financial instruments between financial institutions when at least one party to the transaction is located in the eu.
Eu financial transaction tax proposed for 11 member states. The european commission has proposed that the tax should come into effect from 1 january 2014. The revised assessment concludes that a ftt would have a positive impact on eu gdp growth contrary to the initial assessment which concluded that impact on gdp growth would be negative. The eesc believes that assessment of the impact of the ftt should cover the effects of the longterm reduction in gdp as estimated by the commissions impact assessment as well as the global effects of its contribution. The revenue potential of a financial transaction tax for u. In this newsflash, we look specifically at the impact of the eu ftt on the asset management industry. In terms of unleashing a torrent of abuse, it even edges out the european commission. Particularly, the overall impact of the financial transaction tax considering cascade effects of securities tax rate 2. The proposed tax is to have a broad base, including most financial transactions equities, bonds, derivatives, both market traded and overthecounter.
The latest information on the eus ftt proposal and various country ftts. To tackle fragmentation of the single market that an uncoordinated patchwork of national financial transaction taxes would create. On 14 february 20, the european commission issued a new draft council directive to implement an eu financial transaction tax ftt in 11 countries. Such taxes have been proposed by economists of the stature of j. The taxation of energy and the wider impact of climate change has been a key area of focus internationally in recent times. A critical assessment, journal of common market studies, 2014. We focus on analyzing the revenue potential of the inclusive prosperity act that was introduced in the u.
Consider the workload and download free impact assessment templates that could help you structure, format, and suggest relevant content. The european unions decision to introduce a financial. While only 11 eu member states will now apply the eu ftt, the effect is likely to be felt more widely. Levying financial transaction taxes is hardly a new idea. Ftt which are of questionable foundation and compares the ftt with some alternative taxes on the financial sector. In september 2011, the european commission proposed a harmonised financial transaction tax for the entire european union see ip111085. Eu proposes financial transaction tax financial post. Financial transaction taxes in the european union thomas hemmelgarn, gaetan nicodeme, bogdan tasnadi, and pol vermote the merits and demerits of financial transaction taxes have been heavily debated among economists, who remain divided on the effects of the taxes on trading volumes, market liquidity, and quotes volatility. In addition, the commission has performed an impact assessment of such a tax. Certain terms may denote that the tax applies to select instruments, such as the uks stamp duty reserve tax, which is levied on shares. In this way, the domicile of the investment funds will potentially become one of the key. The eu financial transactions tax april 2012 proposal. The eu financial transactions tax latest developments this is the third in our series of newsflashes regarding the proposed introduction of a financial transactions tax ftt within the eu. How a financial transaction tax would benefit us all.
On 14 february 20, the european commission issued a new draft council. Eu financial transaction tax revealed wide ranging tobin tax to have impact well beyond the ftt zone. Macron and the eu financial transaction tax christian. The paper presents an agentbased financial market model and simulations.
Like most selfrespecting capitalists, i just want to be left alone to get on with my business and keep as much of the money i earn as i can. In september 2011, the ec presented a plan for a financial transaction tax that would apply to all 27 eu member states. The concept has been most commonly associated with the financial sector. For example, the inclusive prosperity act proposed by sen. Pdf impact of a financial transaction tax on a financial. We introduce the financial transaction tax, which seems to be coming down the road and, according to an impact assessment conducted by the commission, will cost 1. A financial transaction tax is a levy on a specific type of financial transaction for a particular purpose. European union financial transaction tax wikipedia. Introduction there is no subject certain to raise the hackles of london bankers more than a. Recently, the european commission has launched the idea of a financial transaction tax ftt. In this newsflash we focus on how the debate has developed since december at the level of the eu, including the latest position across the member states. This model is an attempt to simulate the effects of a specific subset of. Keynes and james tobin in past decades and interest has been revived recently by the robin hood tax campaign and a variety of official bodies such as the european commission.
We previously highlighted that the directive has a very broad scope and will impact both eu and noneu financial institutions. Did the new french tax on financial transactions influence. Proposals for a financial transaction tax ftt have surfaced throughout the years in the united states and around the world. Eu financial transaction tax revealed wide ranging. Recently, bills have been introduced in congress that would tax financial transactions at rates of up to 0. Indeed, aside from the effect of the tax on portfolio transactions, the distribution of unitsshares by funds would also be impacted. The directive on the eu ftt that was originally proposed in september 2011 would have covered all. Eurofound launched a largescale online survey across the european union and beyond on 9 april. However, in october 2012, when discussions failed to establish clear unanimous support for an euwide ftt, the 11 proponent countries asked the ec to prepare a revised proposal to be implemented using the enhanced cooperation.
In addition, baldwin 2011 identifies two volatility categories in literature. Brexit kicks eu financial transaction tax into the long. Financial transaction tax the impact of a financial. The european parliaments legislative train schedule monitors the progress of legislative files identified in the 10 priorities of the european commission. If so, the tax would apply to all transactions on financial instruments between financial institutions when at least one party to the transaction is located in a participating country. A financial transaction tax is one of several names for a tax on financial assets. Impact assessments are made possible through different assessment procedures. A european financial transaction tax stamp out poverty. The european union financial transaction tax eu ftt is a proposal made by the european commission to introduce a financial transaction tax ftt within some of the member states of the european union eu the proposed eu financial transaction tax would be separate from a bank levy, or a resolution levy, which some governments are proposing to impose on banks to insure them against the. How would the ftt impact the eu gdp and what is its revenue raising. This report assesses the impact of the proposed eu financial transaction tax ftt on. Assessing the impact of an eu financial transactions tax.
Annex 3 the impact of the ftt on eu11 financial markets. The european union financial transaction tax eu ftt is back on the agenda. Stephan schulmeister, margit schratzenstaller, oliver picek, a general financial transaction tax. A formative assessment could be embodied in an entire impact assessment process and be taken as a whole. Similar bills have been proposed in previous congresses. Euro tax flash issue 188 pdf 53 kb 27 june 2012 council orientation debate on the eu financial transaction tax. In its work to assess the macroeconomic impacts of a financial transaction tax specifically, the european commissions economists developed a new dynamic stochastic general equilibrium dsge model. At the ecofin meeting on december 5, 2019, the eu council adopted the draft conclusions on the eu energy taxation framework the conclusions invite the european commission to take measures to ensure a transition to a climateneutral eu in line with commitments. On this principle, taxation would be independent of the transactions location. Eu financial transaction tax a europewide financial transaction tax ftt was initially proposed by the european commission ec in september 2011 with the following objectives. The history of the proposal on financial transaction tax.
709 686 1186 648 1133 457 1052 1411 417 1415 513 208 1143 331 275 464 1416 494 607 678 1348 10 1017 1410 50 871 516 89 1439 740 872 495 592 1363 1195 524 1313 1246 1334 230